Thursday, December 13, 2007

MEDIA MISINFORMS: Fewer Soldiers Commit Suicide During Bush Years

USA Today has the latest attempt by the media to try to shape opinion on the War in Iraq:

A record number of soldiers — 109 — have killed themselves this year, according to Army statistics showing confirmed or suspected suicides.

The deaths occur as soldiers serve longer combat deployments and the Army spends $100 million on support programs.

The Army provided suicide statistics to Sen. Patty Murray, D-Wash. Her staff shared them with USA TODAY.

The Army updated those statistics Wednesday, confirming 85 suicides, including 27 in Iraq and four in Afghanistan.
Of course, if there is a correlation between suicides and Iraq it is not clear from this article since the vast majority of the Army suicides did not occur in Iraq and no information is shared by Senator Murray on whether these soldiers ever spent time in Iraq.

But, facts don't matter to Senator Murray or the media.
It's all about agenda.

Senator Murray knows better.
A report released to Congress in July of this year showed that military suicides are much lower during the Bush years than the Clinton years.

Here's a closer look at the official numbers:

Click to Enlarge
From page 11 of the CRS Report to Congress (pdf)
-Hat Tip BG

If you look at the numbers you see that the total official number of suicides in the military last year was 155. If you look further you see that there are less suicides in the military today than during the Clinton years!

What do you suppose drove our soldiers to commit suicide when the Clintons were in office?
And, how will the media explain this?

And... US soldiers are also less likely to commit suicide than the general population.
Poynter Online reported:

The 17/100,000 rate is right on track with what the rate is for all males in the United States...

When you consider that most serving in Iraq are young, you might find that the suicide rate among those serving in Iraq could be even less than their peers in the general population. The suicide rate for 20 to 24-year-old males in the United States is 20/100,000 [pdf].
And, this figure (18.4) reported by USA Today is actually lower than the general population for that age group.

WORD TO THE WISE: Don't trust Patty Murray (D-Wash)!

Flopping Aces has more on these suicide numbers.

Previously:
Since Clintons Left Office Fewer Soldiers Kill Themselves

5 Comments:

Blogger Just A Grunt said...

Thanks for tracking down those numbers. One other area that needs to be looked at it is Active Duty versus Reserve/National Guard. I think if you break it down that way you find the active duty number is even lower. Reservists suffer from much more stress then their Active Duty counterparts do and it isn't necessarily just the stress of combat that contributes. For reservists it is the separation and financial worries also.
Being a vet the numbers looked right but they certainly don't appear to be above average. I remember whenever I was stationed overseas when the Thanksgiving/Christmas season arrived the NCO's would be called in and once again instructed to look for the signs and symptoms.
The liberals just have this incredible need to make victims out of everybody, even those who don't consider themselves victims.

1:19 PM  
Blogger juandos said...

Well this is hardly the first time the members of the party of the Seditious & Sleazy tried to foist off nonsense about the troops onto the public...

Remember Sen. lying Loser Kerry's comments about the soldiers?

Oddly enough a little investigation by the Heritage Foundation found a completely different picture...

3:22 PM  
Blogger Mike O said...

If I had to serve with a Clinto as Commander-in-Chief, I know I'd be a lot more tempted to end my misery.

7:22 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

You are badly misleading your readers......the suicide rate for the current group of soldiers is off the chart. And it comes as no surprise given the conditions in Iraq. Why you refuse to believe that war is hell and bad for Americans is beyond me. I guess its stinkin' thinkin'.

Suicide Epidemic Among Veterans

A CBS News Investigation Uncovers A Suicide Rate For Veterans Twice That Of Other Americans

http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2007/11/13/cbsnews_investigates/main3496471.shtml

8:55 PM  
Anonymous erick said...

Why would you use a benchmark year, five years after a major
conflict. Lets compare the numbers to 4 years into a major conflict; say 1969-70. And see if there are
any similarities

6:01 PM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home