Greyhawk has several photos from the air above Iraq and writes this about the victory, via Instapundit:
A few days ago I posted this entry at MilBlogs:We've won the war.I wanted to say that with a very short and to the point post, with none of the ifs, ors or buts that a more reticent observer may have tossed in. I recognize now I should have extended my entry to six words: "We've won the war in Iraq".
I expect that the statement will unnerve the war's supporters who fear that the next act of violence in Iraq will offer the war's opponents yet another opportunity to insist we're defeated - or at least in a "quagmire" - but it's still a fact (as is that next act of violence). And I realize the degree of rage this will invoke in those opposed to our efforts - at least those who are politically opposed - but given the magnitude of their investment in defeat it should surprise no one if twenty years from now they're still insisting we lost. As for those engaged in actual armed combat against us, I addressed them in my first followup to that original post:Lt. Gen. Odierno is absolutely right to note: "it only takes three people" to construct and detonate a suicide car bomb that can "kill thousands". And John Kerry was wrong when claiming (in an effort to undermine homefront morale in another war) that no one wants to be the last man to die for a mistake. In fact, al Qaeda will always have someone eager to prove him wrong.Being in Iraq I can assure you that along with the al Qaeda exclusion there's a corollary to that Kerry quote that must also be acknowledged: No one wants to be the last man to die for a victory, either. But either way, someone will be "that guy".
Yes, they could pull off a "Tet". Hell, they could manage something like their own version of the battle of the bulge, but the reality is they're whipped.
++
ReplyDeletethanks GP..
it's been heavenly w/o the constant flow of bad news, but boring because the good news is hard to find.. funny thing is, i have a feeling that there was probably more good news than there ever was bad.. ;)
at any rate call me a believer.. because they don't hold back many punches @ The Mudville Gazette.. (thumbsup)
God Bless Soldiers everywhere for putting THEIR
lives on the line to protect us ALL from terrorism!
==
BG- Agreed.
ReplyDeleteI would trust the milbloggers over the MSM any day on news from Iraq.
My husband's been in Baghdad since November and before that most of 2004 and 2005. Today on the phone he told he was stunned because it really looks like it is over. The insurgency has collapsed so fast that it is mind boggling. There has been so much work done beyond the obvious and it is paying off.
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely, bg. No news is good news, as they say. The really big events have given way to slow but steady building and the normal game of politics. The next big turning point will be in a couple of years when Iraqis get to go the the polls again. If they manage to a pull off a reasonably safe and corruption free election, that will be a major milestone. Lets hope some secular parties have more prominence next time and that real campaigning can take place because the fear of bombs and reprisals will have been reduced to a minimum. Iraq is gonna make it.
ReplyDeleteForget Tet. That was a massive assault by NV troops and such VC as were still standing, and resulted in a huge military defeat for the North. there is no such pool of organized fighters in AQ, there is nowhere for them to assemble, etc. They are limited to local atrocities and reigns of terror -- or have been. Now, even that is a stretch.
ReplyDeleteThey may get a big bomb or two in place here and there. But massive military attacks? Forget it.
Are there any really Fat female Democrat senators in Washington?
ReplyDeleteWe need her to Sing.
Just to qualify my previous post, a bit: Waziristan could be an assembly point for big numbers, but that's not AQ as such. And if ISI could have retained and deepened its "control" of Anbar and Diyala and Babil, e.g., there were possible big-numbers assemblies. But pre-Surge and spotty-COIN MNF forces had been more than equal to, in fact hoped for, stand-up challenges of any kind.
ReplyDeleteAnd even the big-bomb that kills "thousands" is pushing it. IIRC, none to date has even managed "hundreds" (i.e., 200+) at one time.
And as for the "Bulge" ... see "Waziristan", above. But short of an outright Islamist takeover of Pakistan, I don't see it.
The news on the ground is getting better and the folks are starting to notice. Not only are attacks down, civil services are improving, and even Fallujah has a functioning local government. These things are not lost on the folks. A new Harris poll sees the numbers improving greatly on the war.
ReplyDeleteHere is how I saw it.
http://proprietornation.blogspot.com/2007/10/situation-in-iraq-continues-to-improve.html